Holly, Fenton

Another of Fenton's very popular patterns and found in quite a range of colors. Sometimes referred to as Carnival Holly. Shapes include plates and bowls, rosebowls made from the same mold as the plates and bowls, hats, and the little stemmed compotes. The plate above left is in aqua opal, the only one known: Courtesy of John Mikkonen. Rosebowls, such as that on the right, are quite rare, but prices don't seem to reflect the rarity. Fenton reissued bowls in aqua opal and amethyst.

Hartung Book One: Holly

Plates, 9-10 inches

Amber, 335 (2005), 175 (2019)

Amethyst/purple, 75, 90, 110, 120, 150 (all 2020),
   70, 110, 130, 170 (all 2021),
   50, 75, 110 (all 2022)

Amethyst, black, 230 (2012),
   200, 225 (both 2018), 200 (2022)

Aqua, 1,400 (2008), 850 (2010), 350 (2017)

Aqua opal, two known, 22,000 (2014),
   8,500 (2017), 3,500 (2022)

Blue, 45, 60, 70, 75, 80, 90, 95, 110, 120, 135, 140, 150, 600 (all 2021),
   50, 65, 70, 85, 100 (all 2022)

Blue, iridized back only, 50 (2016), 25 (2020)

Blue, red iridized, 260 (2021)

Blue, spectacular irid, 1,000 (2015)

Blue, mauve iridescense, 650 (2015)

Blue, smokey, 650 (2006)

Blue violet, 250 (2006)

Celeste blue, 5,000 (2017),
   1,700 16,000 (both 2022)

Champagne, 45 (2013)

Clambroth, 50, 85 (both 2013), 80 (2015),
   5, 20, 40 (all 2021)

Green, 85, 95, 120, 180 (all 2020),
   95, 100, 135, 145, 275 (all 2021),
   90, 95, 110, 130, 170 (all 2022)

Green, Karen Engel auction, 1,000 (2017)

Ice blue, 1,500 (2021)

Ice green, one or two known, 16,000 (2014),
   2,600 (2022)

Lavender, 185 (2003), 800 (2008)

Marigold, 25, 35, 40, 50, 60, 65, 70 (all 2020),
   10, 20, 35. 40, 45, 55, 65, 85 (all 2021),
   10, 25, 40, 45, 50, 75, 200 (all 2022)

Marigold, rainbow irid., 500 (2021)

Marigold, yellow stretchy irid., 800 (2016)

Marigold, pastel, 300 (2012)

Olive green, 200 (2004), 160 (2006), 225 (2012)

Oxblood, 575 (2008)

Pink, 1,800 (2001), 1,900 (2015)

Peach opal, 4,250 (2021)

Peach opal, Karen Engel auction, 4,100 (2017)

Red, 4,500 (2011), 650 (2013), 2,000 (2014)

Teal, 160, 1,000 (both 2018), 130 (2019),
   70 (2021), 300 (2022)

White, 25, 30, 40, 50, 55, 65, 100 (all 2020),
   35, 45, 60 (all 2021), 40. 50 (both 2022)

White, amethyst streaks, 400 2018)

Yellow, 5,250 (2022)

Above is the first known red Holly plate. It sold on eBay in 2005 for $5,250.

This is the first known Holly plate in ice blue. It sold in 2021 for $1,500. Photo courtesy of Sheffield auctions..

Bowls, about 9 inches, ruffled, 3/1, or crimped

Amber, 35, 60, 65 (all 2016), 70 (2018),
   20, 40 (both 2021), 35 (2022)

Amber, red edge, 120 (2021)

Amber opal, 375 (2009)

Amethyst/purple, 20, 30, 40 (all 2019), 20 (2020),
   35, 40 (both 2021), 15, 35, 45 (all 2022)

Amethyst, black, 95 (2016), 30, 85 (both 2019),
   75 (2021)

Amberina, 300, 325 (both 2017), 360 (2020),
   130 (2021)

Amberina, reverse, 325 (2012)

Amberina, slag effect, 900 (1998), 375 (2001)

Aqua/teal, 45, 225, 310 (all 2020),
   100, 195 (both 2021)

Aqua opal, one ruffled known, 16,000 (2014)

Blue, 10, 15, 30, 40, 45, 50, 75, 150 (all 2021),
   20, 25, 35, 40, 50 (all 2022)

Blue, cobalt, 350 (2019), 210 (2022)

Blue, cobalt, only iridized on back, 30 (2022)

Blue, unusual 2/1 edge, 190 (2013)

Blue, 7 1/4-inch nut bowl, 25 (2018)

Blue, electric, 425 (2005), 400 (2008)

Blue opal, 250, 675 (both 2020),
   550, 750, 800 (all 2021), 575, 600 (both 2022)

Blue, powder, 45, 55, 110 (all 2017), 70 (2020),
   40 (2022)

Celeste blue, 675 (2019), 1,300 (2020),
   3,250 (2021), 1,700, 2,200 (both 2022)

Clambroth, 15 (2013)

Green, 20, 40, 70 (all 2020),
   20, 30, 35, 40, 45, 50 (all 2021),
   30, 40, 45 (all 2022)

Ice green, six ruffles 3,000 (2019), 1,600 (2021)

Lavender, 95 (2012), 35 (2015), 50 (2018),
   45 (2021)

Lime green, 45, 50, 60 (all 2016), 50 (2018),
   35, 40 (both 2019)

Lime green, 7 1/2-inch nut bowl shape,
   160 (2018), 130 (2022)

Marigold, 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, 45, 195 (all 2021),
   10, 20, 40 (both 2022)

Marigold, white slag base, 340 (2004)

Marigold on milk glass, 205 (2018), 165 (2021),
   200 (2022)

Marigold on moonstone, 225 (2020),
   250, 375, 450 (all 2021),
   275, 400, 550 (all 2022)

Olive green, 75 (2003)

Peach opal, 450 (2013), 300 (2015), 500 (2016),
   375 (2021)

Pink, 70 (2012), 55 (2014), 45 (2020)

Plum opal, 200 (2007)

Red, 90, 100, 110, 135, 140, 200, 275, 350, 375 (all 2021), 100, 150, 160, 240 (all 2022)

Red, oxblood, 75 (2020), 270 (2022)

Sapphire blue, 95 (2007)

Smoke, 130 (2011)

Teal, 235 (2012), 100 (2013), 55 (2019),
   160 (2021)

Vaseline, 150 (2020), 55, 65, 80, 105 (all 2021)

White, 25 (2019), 25, 40 (both 2020),
   15, 20, 25 (all 2021), 30, 40 (both 2022)

Bowls, 8--9 inches, ice cream shape or round

Amber, 55 (2015), 100, 130 (both 2018),
   50 (2021), 375 (2022)

Amberina, 800 (2008), 420 (2010)

Amethyst, 40 (2018), 25, 30, 85 (all 2019),
   50, 60, 65, 70 (all 2021), 40 (2022)

Aqua/teal, 350 (1996), 90 (2004), 40 (2017),
   80 (2021)

Blue, 25, 35, 40, 195 (all 2019),
   10, 25 (both 2020), 20, 50, 55 (all 2021),
   25, 60 (both 2022)

Blue, electric, 500 (2021)

Blue, powder, 40 (2012), 60 (2018), 25 (2020)

Celeste blue, 1,500, 4,250 (both 2017),
   1,800, 2,600 (both 2018), 1,700 (2022)

Clambroth, 13 (2014), 15 (2022)

Green, 30, 40 (both 2019), 70 (2020),
   35, 40 (both 2021), 25, 40 (both 2022)

Green, emerald, 525 (2014)

Ice blue, 2,700 (1993)

Ice green, 2,150 (1995)

Ice green, weak irid., 100 (2009), 250 (2016)

Lime green, 95 (2003), 40 (2014)

Marigold, 40 (2019), 275 (2020),
   15, 30 (both 2021), 10, 20 (both 2022)

Marigold on milkglass,
   15, 30 (both 2021), 350, 375 (both 2022)

Marigold on moonstone, 225 (2009), 210 (2017),
   325 (2021)

Peach opal, 400 (2021)

Red, 575, 600 (both 2014), 425 (2018),
   475 (2019)

Vaseline, 65 (2003), 135 (2004), 50 (2011)

White, 55 (2009), 60 (2011), 45 (2015),
   40 (2018), 30 (2022)

Rosebowls

Blue, 45 (2010), 60 (2012), 45 (2017), 100 2018),
   130 (2022)

Blue, nut bowl shape, 35 (2021)

Marigold, 35 (2014), 60 (2016), 5, 30 (both 2017),
   25 (2021), 30 (2022)

Vaseline known

Holly hats are found in a variety of top shapes. The red crimped jack-in-the-pulpit shown here is fairly common, as is red in most shapes. The compotes are also found with a variety of top shapings.

Holly Hat article

Hats, ruffled and/or crimped

Amber, 25 (2014), 45 (2016), 15 (2019),
   15 (2020), 60 (2022)

Amber opal, 125 (2009)

Amberina, 40 (2012), 100 (2016), 40 (2018)

Amberina, reverse, 160 (2014)

Amethyst/purple, 10, 20 (2010), 10 (2015),
   15, 25 (both 2016), 15 (2020)

Amethyst opal, 65 (2019), 120 (2020)

Aqua/teal, 15, 50 (both 2020),
   10, 25 (both 2021)

Aqua opal, 225 (2013), 200 (2014),
   110 (2020)

Blue, 15 (2017), 10 (2018),
   5, 10, 30 (all 2021), 45 (2022)

Blue, powder, 35 (2000)

Green, 10, 14 (2014), 40 (2016), 10 (2020)

Honey Amber, 25 (2020)

Lavender, 38 (2002)

Lavender opal, 125 (1995), 50 (2004)

Lime green, 15 (2015), 15 (2016), 20 (2020)

Marigold, 5 (2017), 10, 15 (both 2019),
   10 (2020)

Marigold on milk glass, 160 (2017),
   150 (2020), 65 (2021)

Marigold on moonstone, 65 (2017),
   390 (2018), 80, 110 (both 2020), 60, 85 (both 2022)

Red, 50, 60, 75, 85, 95, 135, 180 (all 2020),
   50, 65, 70, 85, 90, 100 (all 2021), 40 (2022)

Red slag, 120 (2016), 75 (2021)

Sapphire, Marigold over, 100 (2022)

Vaseline, 33 (2013), 5 (2017), 20 (2019),
   35 (2021)

Hat, 2 sides up

Amberina, 80 (2020), 20 (2021)

Aqua, 30 (2005), 50 (2009), 30 (2018),
   10 (2022)

Blue, 15, 25 (both 2015), 15, 35 (both 2016),
   30 (2022)

Blue, powder or pale, 30-50

Lime green, 120 (2003), 30 (2004), 25 (2020),
   10 (2022)

Marigold, 10-15

Red, 50, 55, 155 (all 2020),
   60, 65 (both 2021), 10 (2022)

Vaseline, 85 (2009), 20 (2013)

Hat, jack-in-the-pulpit shape, usually crimped

Amber, 50 (2009, 30 (2011), 35 (2016),
   30 (2020)

Amberina, 205 (1999)

Amethyst/purple, 45 (2004), 10 (2016)

Aqua/teal, 200 (1994), 115 (2003)

Blue, 60 (2013), 20 (2016), 30 (2020)

Green, 360 (2012), 275 (2013), 65 (2017)

Lime green, 120 (2003), 60 (2014)

Marigold, 10 (2014), 5 (2020),10 (2021)

Red, 225 (2018), 100 (2019), 95 (2020),
   80 (2021)

Vaseline, 55 (2016), 170 (2018), 25 (2019)

Hat, square or 4 sided

Amber, 25 (2014), 30 (2016)

Amber slag, 30 (2019)

Amberina, 125 (2003)

Amethyst, 20 (2004)

Aqua, 40 (2015), 25 (2020), 30 (2021)

Blue, 30 (2013), 20 (2016)

Blue, powder, 20 (2018), 20 (2019)

Green, 50 (2003), 3 (2017)

Lime green, 30 (2013)

Marigold, 5 (2013), 5 (2014), 7, 8 (both 2015)

Peach opal, 85 (2008)

Red, 125 (2000), 240 (2002), 140 (2010)

Sapphire blue, 33 (2010), 10 (2020)

Vaseline, 35 (2004), 50 (2014), 120 (2020)

Updated 9/13/2022

Compotes, any shaped top
Comments by Alan and Lorraine Pickup

Amber, 75 (2003), 125 (2020), 40 (2022)

Amberina, 150 (2017), 270 (2018), 145 (2021),
   160 (2022)

Amethyst/purple, 20, 45 (both 2017),
   10, 15 (both 2018), 10, 15, 20, 30 (all 2020),
   35 (2022)

Amethyst, black, 65 (2015), 80 (2016),
   15 (2020), 100 (2022)

Amethyst, black, 2 sides up, 250 (2017),
   25 (2020)

Aqua/teal, 20. 30. 45 (all 2019), 20 (2021)

Blue, 10 (2019), 10, 20 (both 2020),
   5, 10, 15, 25, 30 (all 2021), 20 (2022)

Blue, 3/1 edge, 120 (2012)

Blue, powder, 15 (2019), 20 (2020),
   15, 30 (both 2021), 60 (2022)

Cobalt blue, 2 sides up, 60 (2021)

Green, 25 (2017), 10 (2019), 25 (2020),
   15, 45, 60 (all 2022)

Lavender, 30 (2018), 5 (2019), 35 (2020)

Lime green, 10, 20 (both 2019), 10 (2020),
   40, 50 (both 2021), 15 (2022)

Lime green vaseline, 240 (2012)

Lime green opal, 325 (2008),
   100, 400 (both 2020), 180, 225, 250, 525 (all 2022)

Marigold, 10, 20 (both 2020), 5, 10 (both 2021),
   5 (2022)

Marigold, 2 sides up, 65 (2012), 15 (2019)

Mauve, 30, 45 (both 2020)

Olive green, 85 (2003)

Pink, 10 (2012), 10, 55 (both 2017), 20 (2021)

Red, 75, 85, 105, 110, 120, 135, 300 (all 2020),
   110, 140, 170, 325 (all 2021),
   120, 125, 130, 150, 230 (all 2022)

Red/Amberina, 190 (2022)

Red opal, 1,600 (1994), 1,200 (1995)

Sapphire blue, 30, 50 (both 2020)

Vaseline, 10, 20, 25, 35 (all 2020), 45 (2021),
   25, 50, 60, 65 (all 2022)

Vaseline opal, 265 (2010), 260 (2014),
   165 (2020)

Violet, 300 (1999), 150 (2003)

White, 300 (2012), 675 (2018), 525 (2020)