Curved Star, Brockwitz/Eda/Karhula

Early Carnival Glass collectors did not know either the pattern or shape of the celery vase on the left, so began calling the pattern Cathedral and the shape as a chalice--and it is still sometimes identified that way. It has only been in relatively recent years that vases have appeared. While the pattern has traditionally been credited to Brockwitz, Glen Thistlewood has pointed out that Eda and Karhula also made the pattern.

Hartung Book Two: Curved Star

Celery vases

Blue, 75, 150 (both 2010),
   135, 200 (both 2012),
   120 (2014), 90 (2016)

Marigold, 10, 20, 25 (all 2014),
   15 (2015), 10, 15 (both 2016)
Cylindrical vases, 7 1/2 inch to 9 1/2 inch

Blue, 140 (2008), 130 (2011), 135 (2012),
   135 (2015), 40, 70, 130 (all 2016)

Marigold, 175 (2004), 165 (2005),
   20, 165 (both 2006), 40 (2007),
   25, 35, 45 (all 2016)

Water pitcher

Blue, 778 (eBay 2005)

Curved Star was produced in a large range of shapes, including this stemmed Creamer and Sugar. The open stemmed sugar is often identified as a compote. The sugar bowls are found with a pattern on the inside called Headdress. Butter dishes are known in two shapes although one is actually a cheese dish.
Butter dishes

Marigold, 30 (2009), 15 (2012),
   20, 25 (both 2016)

Creamers

Blue, 50 (2009), 20 (2013)

Marigold, 5 (2016)

Sugar, ruffled, Headdress interior

Blue, 50-80

Marigold, 20-30

Creamer and open sugar

Marigold, 23 (2007), 10 (2016)

Covered marmalade

Marigold, 250 (1999)

Wine tray

Marigold, 15 (2016)

Cake plate, 7 inches across, 3 inches high

Blue, 75 (2000), 20 (2016)

Compote (or sugar), usually Headdress interior

Blue, 35, 50 (both 2013), 65 (2014),
   35 (2015)

Marigold, 5, 10, 18 (all 2012),
   5, 10 (both 2013), 20 (2014), 23 (2015), 15 (2016)

Marigold, covered, stemmed, 20 (2016)

Compote, covered, with underplate

Marigold, 300 (2004)

Flower pot with frog

Blue, 110 (2016)

Marigold, 110 (2009), 80 (2011),
   70 (2014), 35, 65 (both 2016)

Child's dish

Marigold, 175 (1998)

Punch or fruit bowl and base

Marigold, 290 (2000), 125 (2010),
   35, 90 (both 2016)

Cheese dish

Marigold, 170 (2012)

Rosebowls are farily common in Curved Star. They vary in size from about 4 inches to about 7 inches across. Bowls are less often seen; the square bowl above is quite unusual. In marigold, it sold for $300 in 1999.
Rosebowls, 4-7 inches

Blue, 110 (2004), 100 (2006), 90 (2012),
   25 (2016)

Marigold, 35 (2010), 10, 25, 30 (all 2016)
Bowls, round, 8-9 inches

Blue, 20, 45 (both 2013), 85 (2014), 45 (2016)

Blue, oval, 85 (2016)

Marigold, 3, 8, 17 (all 2012)

Marigold, oval, 10 (2016)

Marigold, square, 80 (2016)

Marigold, 11 inches, Headdress inter.,
   45 (2015), 5 (2016)

Small bowl or sauce, about 5 inches

Marigold, 10-20

The Curved Star epergne is quite rare. This example is courtesy of Ed Kramer. Note that the top is the same as the candlestick holder--another example of how some European manufacturers made pieces do double duty. The candlestick holders were identified as Star and Fan when they sold for $205 in 1993. A marigold epergne sold in 2003 for $1,100; another in 2004 for $350, and another in 2011 for $550. In 2016, a marigold example with minor damage brought $350.

Updated 2/16/2017

King Hoppel sent me this photo of a graduated set of Curved Star bowls. Who knew they made so many sizes?