Circle Scroll, Dugan

Recognized by its large circular panel with a scroll design inside, Circle Scroll is found in a limited number of shapes--many rare. The most often seen shape is the hat, usually jack-in-the-pulpit, 2 sides up, tricorner, or ruffled--all made from the tumbler. Surprisingly, the tumbler itself is quite scarce. Pitchers are rare. The marigold example above, with a slight flaw in the rim, sold with the tumbler in 2001 for $500. Bowls and berry sets are also quite scarce, but seldom bring much money. The large amethyst bowl on the right sold for $65 in 2002, one of the few known. Although table set pieces are known, they rarely come up for sale.

Hartung Book Two: Circled Scroll

Water set, 7 piece

Marigold, 375 (2007)

Water pitcher

Marigold, 305 (2005), 210 (2008), 400 (2014)

Pitcher, 1 tumbler

Marigold, flaw in rim, 500 (2001)

Tumblers

Amethyst/purple, 310 (2004), 190 (2006),
   325 (2012)

Marigold, 130 (2007), 40 (2009), 155 (2010),
   120 (2012), 130 (2013), 80 (2015), 35 (2016)

Hats, from tumbler, ruffled, JIP, tricorner,
or 2 sided


Marigold, 150, 160 (both 2014),
   35, 45, 55, 60, 90 (all 2015),
   15, 30, 45 (all 2016), 110 (2017)

Marigold, JIP, souvenir lettering,
   75 (2006), 55 (2015), 65 (2016)

Purple, 30, 80, 110 (all 2013),
   85, 150 (both 2014), 115, 125 (both 2015),
   55 (2016), 225 (2017)

Purple, tricorner, souvenir lettering,
   45 (2006), 120 (2016)

Table set, 4 piece

Marigold, 425 (2007), 400 (2016)

Purple, no sugar lid, damage, 275 (2012)

Butter, creamer, spooner (sold as set)

Marigold, 275 (2012), 170 (2017)

Butter dish

Known in marigold and purple

Creamer

Marigold, 55 (2006)

Purple, 95 (1997), 55 (2003)

Spooner

Marigold, 90 (2000)

Purple, 175 (2000), 75 (2010), 130 (2014)

Sugar bowl with lid

Marigold, 120 (2016)

Berry sets, 7 pieces

Marigold, 150 (2010)

Bowl, large berry

Amethyst, 65 (2002)

Amethyst, chips in pattern, 30 (2016)

Marigold, 9 1/4-inch round, 125 (2016)

Above is an amethyst small bowl from the collection of Larry Keig.

Bowl, small berry or sauce

Amethyst, 25 (1995), 35 (2015)

Marigold, 28 (1999)

Updated 7/19/2017

The vases are unusual in that they were made from the tumbler, rather than their own special mold. The base is 2 1/2 inches and they generally fall into the height range of 6 to 9 inches. These purple and marigold vases are shown with a typical ruffled hat.

Amethyst, black, 135 (2005), 160 (2009)

Marigold, 75, 140, 260 (all 2012),
   65, 125 (both 2014), 70 (2015),
   20, 45, 55, 60, 65, 70, 150 (all 2016)

Purple, 230 (2012), 140, 225 (both 2013),
   140, 150, 165, 250, 295 (all 2014),
   95, 130, 225, 250 (all 2015),
   120, 150, 275, 345, 400 (all 2016),
   100 (2017)

Purple, 6 1/2-inch, 800 (2013)